As an independent insurance agent, we represent a number of different insurance companies, and act as an advocate on your behalf to help choose the best one for your particular situation. Each company has slightly different underwriting philosophies, appetites and pricing models. What that means to you is that there are some companies that view your situation as risky, and charge more, while others may view your situation as less risky and charge less. We can help point you in the right direction and find a financially-sound company that is just right for your particular situation.
The following is a list of the insurance companies we represent along with their website addresses and phone numbers should you have to contact them directly.
AAA – Wisconsin
Address 8401 Excelsior Boulevard Madison Wisconsin 53717 United States
General Inquiries: 800-236-1300
Website
Billing website
Claims website
Acuity
Address 2800 South Taylor Drive PO Box 58 Sheboygan WI 53081
General Inquiries: 800-242-7666
Website
Billing Website
Claims Website
American Modern
Address P.O. Box 5323 Cincinnati OH 45201
General Inquiries: 800-543-2644
Billing: 800-543-2644
Claims: 800-375-2075
Website
Billing Website
Claims Website
Auto-Owners
Address 6101 Anacapri Blvd. Lansing MI 48917
General Inquiries: (517) 323-1200
Claims: (517) 323-1200
Website
Claims Website
Billing Website
Badger Mutual Insurance Company
Address 1635 West National Avenue Milwaukee WI 53204
General Inquiries: 800-837-7833
Website
Billing Website
Claims Website
Banner Life (Legal and General NA)
Address 3275 Bennett Creek Avenue Frederick MD 21704
General Inquiries: (800) 638-8428
Website
Claim Website
Berkshire Hathaway Homestate Companies
Address P.O. Box 2048 Omaha NE 68103
General Inquiries: 888-495-8949
Website
Billing Website
Claims Website
Capital Indemnity/Cap Specialty
Address 1600 Aspen Commons Middleton WI 53562
General Inquiries: 800-475-4450
Website
Billing Website
Claims Website
CNA
Address 333 S Wabash Ave Chicago IL 60604
General Inquiries: 800-262-2000
Claims: 800-262-2727
Work Fax: 877-276-7507
Website
Billing Website
Dairyland Auto
Address P.O. Box 8021 Stevens Point WI 54481-8021
General Inquiries: 800-334-0090
Billing: 800-334-0090
Claims: 800-334-0090
website
Billing Website
Claims Website
Employers
Address PO Box 539004 Henderson NV 89503
General Inquiries: 888-682-6671
Claims: 800-232-3085
Website
Billing Website
Claims Website
Encompass Insurance
Address 3100 Sanders Rd Northbrook IL 60062
General Inquiries: 847-844-6100
Claims: 800-588-7400
Work Fax: 866-430-2916
Website
Billing Website
Claims Website
Foremost
Address PO Box 0915 Carol Stream IL 60132-0915
General Inquiries: 800-527-3905
Billing: 800-532-4221
Claims: 800-527-3907
Website
Billing Website
Claims Website
Germantown Mutual Insurance Company
Address W209 N11845 Insurance Place P.O. Box 1020 Germantown WI 53022-8220
General Inquiries: (262) 251-6680
Claims: 800-236-4642
Website
Claims Website
Guardian
Address 2300 East Capitol Drive Appleton WI 54911
General Inquiries: 920-749-9200
Hagerty
Address P.O. Box 1303 Traverse City MI 49685-1303
General Inquiries: (877) 922-9701
Website
Claim Wesite
Billing Website
HIRSP Authority
Address 1751 W. Broadway P.O. Box 8961 Madison WI 53708-8961
General Inquiries: (800) 828-4777
Website
Integrity Insurance
Address 2121 East Capitol Drive PO Box 539 Appleton WI 54912-0539
General Inquiries: 800-348-1741
Billing: 888-699-9182
Claims: 800-445-3030
Website
Billing Website
Claims Website
Jewelers Mutual Insurance Company
Address 24 Jewelers Park Dr Neenah WI 54956
General Inquiries: 800-558-6411
Claims: 888-884-2424
Work Fax: 888-884-2424
Website
Billing Website
Claims Website
Kemper
Address One East Wacker Drive Chicago IL 60601
General Inquiries: 866-860-9348
Claims: 866-536-7376
Website
Claims Website
Lancer Insurance Company
Address 370 West Park Ave PO Box 9004 Long Beach NY 11561
General Inquiries: 800-782-8902 x3307
Claims: 800-521-6155
Work Fax: 800-782-8902 x3901
Website
Claims Website
Liberty Mutual (Indiana)
Address “‘11611 N. Meridian St, Ste 105′” Carmel IN 46032
General Inquiries: 800-379-2959
Claims: 800-225-2467
Work Fax: 800-225-8285
Website
Billing Website
Claims Website
Main Street America
Address 15490 101st Avenue North Maple Grove MN 55369
General Inquiries: 800-328-4628
Claims: 877-425-2467
Work Fax: 888-333-4014
Website
Billing Website
Claims Website
MetLife Property and Casualty
General Inquiries: 800-422-4272
Billing: 800-680-3354
Claims: 800-854-6011
Website
Billing Website
Claims Website
Mt. Morris Mutual Insurance Company
Address N1211 County Road B Coloma WI 54930
General Inquiries: 877-228-5541
Claims: 877-228-4199
Website
Claims Website
Billing Website
National General Insurance
Address PO Box 3199 Winston-Salem NC 27102-3199
General Inquiries: 800-325-1088
Claims: 800-325-1088
Work Fax: 800-462-2123
Website
Billing Website
Claims Website
National Interstate Insurance
Address 3250 Interstate Dr Richfield OH 44286
General Inquiries: 800-929-1500
Claims: 800-929-0870
Website
Billing Website
Claims Website
Nationwide
Address PO Box 742522 Cincinnati OH 45274-2522 United States
General Inquiries: 877-669-6877
Billing: 877-262-0247
Claims: 800-421-3535
Website
Billing Website
Claims Website
NSI (a Division of West Bend)
Address PO Box 620976 8401 Greenway Blvd Suite 1100 Middleton WI 53562
General Inquiries: 800-760-9250
Claims: 877-922-5246
Website
Billing Website
Claims Website
Personalumbrella.com
Address 5835 Doyle St Suite 115 Emeryville CA 94608
General Inquiries: 800-564-1799
Work Fax: 800-564-1799
Website
Philadelphia Insurance Companies
Address One Bala Plaza Suite 100 Bala Cynwyd PA 19004
General Inquiries: 877-438-7459
Claims: 800-765-9749
Work Fax: 877-438-7459
Website
Billing Website
Claims Website
Progressive
Address 6300 Wilson Mills Road Mayfield Village OH 44143
General Inquiries: (800) 776-4737
Website
Billing Website
Claim Website
Protector Insurance
Address 1500 N Expressway 83 Suite A Brownsville TX 78521
General Inquiries: 956-546-1140
Website
Billing Website
QBE – General Casualty
Address One General Drive Sun Prairie WI 53596
General Inquiries: 608.837.4440
Billing: 800-553-4471
Claims: (888) 737.8256
Website
Billing Website
Claims Website
Rockford Mutual Insurance Company
Address 527 Colman Center Dr PO Box 5626 Rockford IL 61125-5626
General Inquiries: 815-489-3210
Claims: 800-747-7642
Work Fax: 815-489-3178
Website
Billing Website
Claims Website
Safeco Insurance
Address P.O. Box 6476 Carol Stream IL 60197
General Inquiries: 800-332-3226
Claims: 800-332-3226
Work Fax: 888-723-3260
Website
Billing Website
Claims Website
Secura
Address 2401 South Memorial Drive PO Box 819 Appleton WI 54912-0819
General Inquiries: 800-558-3405
Claims: 800-318-2136
Work Fax: 800-830-9150
Secura
Billing Website
Claims Website
Selective
Address 11711 North Meridian Street Suite 800 Carmel IN 46032
General Inquiries: 866-248-0850
Claims: 866-455-9969
Work Fax: 888-974-7400
Website
Billing Website
Claims Website
Sheboygan Falls/Donegal Insurance Group
Address 511 Water St PO Box 159 Sheboygan Falls WI 53085-0159
General Inquiries: 800-242-7698
Claims: 800-242-7698
Website
Billing Website
Claims Website
State Auto Insurance Companies
Address 518 East Broad St Columbus OH 43215
General Inquiries: 800-492-5246
Claims: 800-766-1853
Work Fax: 800-444-9950 x5118
Website
Billing Website
Claims Website
The Hartford
General Inquiries: (800) 624-5578
Billing: (877) 896-9320
Claims: (800) 243-5860
Website
Billing Website
Claims Website
The Travelers – Commercial Lines
Address PO Box 660317 Dallas TX 75266-0317
General Inquiries: (866) 336-2077
Billing: (800) 252-2268
Claims: (800) 238-6225
Website
Billing Website
Claims Website
The Travelers – Personal Lines
Address PO Box 660307 Dallas TX 75266-0307
General Inquiries: (866) 336-2077
Billing: (800) 842-5075
Claims: (800) 252-4633
Website
Billing Website
Claims Website
Transcom General Agency, Inc.
Address 216 North Midvale Blvd PO Box 5368 Madison WI 53705-0368
General Inquiries: 800-360-3303
Website
Billing Website
Claims Website
United Health One – Golden Rule
United States Liability Group (USLI)
Address 1190 Devon Park Drive PO Box 6700 Wayne PA 19087
General Inquiries: 800-523-5545
Work Fax: 866-632-2003
Website
Billing Website
Claims Website
Vacant Express
Address 125 S. Wacker Dr, Suite 1580′ Chicago IL 60606
General Inquiries: 800-310-3351
Claims: 800-788-4780
Website
Billing Website
Claims Website
West Bend
Address 1900 S 18th Ave West Bend WI 53095
General Inquiries: (800) 236-5010
Website
Billing Website
Claims Website
Wisconsin Mutual Insurance Company
Address 8201 Excelsior Dr Madison WI 53717
General Inquiries: 800-831-5959
Claims: 800-831-5959
Work Fax: 800-831-5959
Website
Billing Website
Claims Website
